Guide 2 of 12 · Strategy · 5 min read
How To Choose Your Early School
The early round is the single highest-leverage decision in this process, and most families spend it on the wrong school. Here is what the data says and what to ignore.
The boost is real, and it is not equal everywhere
Early Decision acceptance rates run roughly two to six times the Regular rate at selective schools. Penn has admitted about 14.7% of early applicants against 4.4% regular. That is the same student facing very different odds.
- Early Decision is binding. Early Action and Restrictive Early Action are not.
- Early Action is a smaller edge. Mostly it just tells you sooner.
- Spend your one binding card where the multiplier is largest, not where the name is biggest.
Only go binding if you would enroll sight unseen
If you would hesitate for even a second after seeing other offers, it is not your Early Decision school. The commitment is the whole reason the boost exists.
- Run the Net Price Calculator before you commit, not after.
- You cannot compare aid packages once you are in.
- If the aid package does not meet your demonstrated need, the Common App agreement releases you. That is the one clean exit.
If you need merit money, think twice
Colleges hold their most attractive merit scholarships to win students over in the Regular round. Applying early can quietly cost you that leverage.
- Need-based aid is formula-driven. Merit aid is competitive.
- If merit money decides whether you can attend, Early Action or Regular is usually the safer route.
Read the restrictive fine print, and keep ED2
Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Stanford and Caltech run restrictive or single-choice Early Action, which limits what else you may file early. A second binding round, ED2, opens in January and carries a similar boost.
- Check each school's exact restriction before you submit anything early.
- Apply Early Action everywhere that is non-restrictive. Those are free extra shots.
- If ED1 does not land, ED2 gives you another binding card at a different school.
One binding card, spent where the boost is biggest and the price already works. Everything else is noise.
Printable version
How To Choose Your Early School
The full workbook as a PDF you can print and write in. We will email it to you.
Get the PDFWant this done with you, not alone?
We build applications that actually get students in.
Our students have been admitted to Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Duke and Cornell, with over $700K in aid. We take a small number each cycle. A call is the fastest way to find out whether your story is working.